My parents live with me and I recently moved my 11 year old niece in to my home due to some domestic issues in her house. For starters, my dad has always been a bit of an a$$hole. But he seems to detest the ground this little child walks on. He hates the fact she’s a picky eater, which isn’t her fault when all she got fed was fast food and chips. He yells when she goes in and out of the house playing, but he’s constantly in and out too!! He seems to even hate her laugh, rudely telling her to hush if she giggles at a volume that he thinks is too loud! I have directly called him out on his behavior but he denies he is being cold toward her. Someone, please tell me why old men are so GROUCHY!! Her feelings are hurt by his attitude toward her and I can’t help her understand this is how he always is. Does anyone have any experience with a situation like this??
In this case, there is no mention of dementia AND OP indicates dad has been a jerk for a long long time. While it may be easy enough for us as adults, esp if we grew up with it, to learn to tune it out, it isn't always that easy. But, even if we 'tune it out', it CAN still impact us, festering way down deep somewhere! For a young one who has already been damaged by abusive home life, this is NOT acceptable and she is going to have a harder time with it than we might.
My kids (esp my daughter) had enough crap from their dad. If I had taken one or both of my parent in and they started on them like this, nope. Kids first. I would either squash this "elder" crap or they would need to move. It wouldn't even matter if the kid(s) were not mine. No. Kids need to have boundaries, but so do adults. Kids need a positive, nurturing environment to grow into responsible adults. If this continues, she will either perpetuate this behavior when she is an adult/parent or it will negatively impact her for the rest of her life!
Don't just tune it out or dismiss it, SQUASH the crap!
How to deal with it depends a lot on what your parents needs are. Are they cognitively okay? Then it would be best to have a heart to heart with them (niece absent from this) and explain that either they (HE) needs to behave while living under your roof. YOUR house, YOUR rules. If he can't abide with this, then other arrangements need to be made. Apartment, IL or AL. If he agrees to try to "behave" and continues, have a set amount of time and monitor his behavior. If he shows improvement, give it more time. If he doesn't within a stated period of time, then they need to move.
If one and/or the other have cognitive and/or medical issues, consider finding a safe place for them, whether it is AL or MC.
Your niece has had a rough time and is at a very impressionable and vulnerable age. She NEEDS to have a stable loving environment (and likely some counseling.) Be VERY supportive of her and take your dad to task whenever he starts his crap. Cut him off as soon as he starts. Do be honest with your niece about him. You can assure her that he's always been a jerk, so she shouldn't take to heart that she is the problem.
While it is commendable that you have taken your parents and your niece in, it is clear that the current situation needs to change. Niece should take priority, as this can affect her entire future! Be firm and strong with your dad. It doesn't matter that he is your father, he needs to be put in his place. He's done this for too long and it is NOT likely that he will change, but if you can work on him and tone it down, possibly it can work, but I certainly wouldn't hold my breath.
As to the original question - most old people are NOT cranky. Sure, they could become cranky, given various medical issues and loss of capabilities, but you stated he's always been "...a bit of an a$$hole.", so having her there is NOT the issue. It is him and he either has to curb it or move. I always told my kids (and even others' kids on teams I was coaching), if you don't have something nice to say, don't say ANYTHING! I would have NO problem telling one of my parents that!
It might be worth sitting down with him and telling him that you are finding it difficult to live with both him and your niece. That your niece’s needs at the moment can’t be met anywhere else, while he is able to move to a facility. If he can’t be more pleasant to both you and your niece, you and he need to start looking for a facility that will suit him. And take the first step – let him know that you are going to look at one, ask if he would like to come along.
This may shock the socks off him, and get him to think about his own best option – being pleasant.
My mom was also in the apartment, and she has dementia. She repeats herself numerous times a minute all day long. I heard from the staff that there had been some verbal altercations (I think she was driving him nuts with all the repetition.)
Towards the end, he got very angry and hollered at me (his oldest,) whenever I visited. He also had the TV turned up way loud and the apartment temperature was in the upper 80's. It was truly unpleasant to visit, which I did at least 3x weekly (other siblings took other days.) He wanted me to get mom out of there so I tried shopping trips, lunches, errands but all she wanted was to get back to "dad." One of his ways of managing her was to have cocktails every evening, and then complain about how much she drank (she had no executive function to regulate her behavior.) But if they ran out of the vile wine she drank, he'd call me up late at night, well after dark, and beg me to go buy wine for her. It was a hour trip to do that. If I couldn't do that (I'm 70 and try not to drive after dark since my night vision is not great,) he'd call other siblings, friends and neighbors to do that.
I was always very close to my dad when growing up. He was a good dad who encouraged achievement by his daughters. He did have a German temper, so the belt came out when we were little. That was how his dad disciplined him when young. But more than this, his behavior before he passed left me with permanent bad memories of him.
Those who were already cranky in younger years are typically worse as they get older. It goes with the territory, but it can be put to good use in society sometimes, e.g. the movie "Gran Torino."
Because they are living in your house put your foot down and let him know there are rules and they will be obeyed. If he refuses then it is time form him to move somewhere else. One of those rules is that he will be respectful towards her.
As for seniors having bad attitudes please keep in mind: they are usually up numerous times during the night have a pee. That means they do not get a good nights sleep
They are frustrated because of their losing a lot of their independence due to loss of physical capabilities. The older they get then more lonely they get because most of their friends have died.
It is unfortunate about his life long abusive behavior but it is good to let your niece know you love her and care about her, not matter where she is living.
Which brings me to my next point: if your father is unable to treat your niece with love and respect, or at least respect, for whatever reason, then either he needs to leave your home or she needs to leave your home. She's no better off in your house, most likely, than she was living in her house where there were domestic issues going on. There's an abusive situation going on in YOUR home, too! Making an excuse for the man by saying 'that's just the way he is' doesn't help your niece process the pain he's causing her. 11 is a particularly delicate age where a young girl needs a nurturing environment so she can develop into an emotionally healthy & stable young woman.
Wishing you the best of luck trying to sort out this difficult situation and create a better living environment for your dear niece. You are a kind person and it shows.
No ifs and or buts.
Moving your niece from one disfunctional home to another is going to cause her more harm.
She needs a home where she can be a child, laugh and play. It will take time for her to trust you and as long as your Dad is abusive she will not develop to her full potential.
Take it slow introducing new foods. If you can take her grocery shopping with you and let her choose a fresh fruit and veggie each week to try. Help her google how to prepare and serve them. Involve her in the prep and cooking. This will give her a sense of ownership over what she eats.
Have a chat with the kid and just tell her old people get cranky and you're sorry he behaves that way. Then, privately, have a chat with him about being a little kinder to a kid that needs some love. Maybe he doesn't really understand what her situation was.
Why will the first child act out when the baby comes?
Have a sit sown discussion with him and tell him "Susie Q" is here to stay. Your goal is to provide a safe and loving environment for her, if he does not want to help with that goal then you will help him (them) find other living arrangement for him. An apartment, Independent Living or Assisted Living that will fit his / their needs. (I am guessing your mom does not have the same issues but same goes for her as well)
Have a sit down discussion with your niece.."Susie Q" and tell her that "Pop" is old and he is sort of comfortable the way things were but he will try his best but you also have to try to get along as well, respect their space, treat both Pop and Mom with respect. And find time each day to sit and talk to them. Learn about them. They will learn about her as well.
Set a ground rule for zero tolerance of nastiness. Basic “Starting today, if we all can’t say something nice around here , we don’t say anything at all: no dirty looks, snide remarks or verbal negative sounds of any kind in order for us all to live together we need to adjust how we talk to each other”.
Keep in mind that includes everyone, in case you might be gruff when talking to him? Or you may harbor some resentment towards him?Sometimes it’s just a family habit of being “honest” to mask resentment and jealousy.
People do change and get cranky with age. My mom is like this; she is 82 years old and very difficult to be with for more than 2 hours. I always think something will change and I would really enjoy her but she is so set in her ways and her body hurst all over that she is just grouchy! Oh, and she argues with me and hangs up the phone if I express how I feel. She never wants to be in a position of vulnerability so she hangs up instead so she has some power.
Two hours is probably an average, mainly if others were around. One on one, no way. I am glad I chose not to take her in when dementia required a safe place (she had been living alone.) She couldn't do stairs then (only way in/out of my place) and bathrooms are too small to make handicap accessible. More recently is refusal to stand/walk without major help, which I can't do (she outweighs me by a lot and lower back condition limits what I can do.)
She didn't become crankier (a bit nasty when we had to move her.) She actually is quite nice now at MC and many staff like her! They didn't grow up with her though.... ;-)